by two sides north america

A recent New York Times investigation revealed a troubling pattern on federal lands: the U.S. Forest Service is putting timber up for sale, and nobody is bidding. In one Colorado sale this summer, 947 acres drew zero interest for the second year in a row. Across the country, loggers passed on 267 million board feet of federal timber in the first three quarters of fiscal 2026.

The consequences are measured in wildfire. More than nine million acres burned across the United States this year, the most since 2015. Without loggers to thin overgrown forests, the dense underbrush that fuels catastrophic fires keeps accumulating.

What’s driving the collapse? In part, it’s the same myth the paper industry has been fighting for years. As The NY Times reported, “digital media is shrinking the paper industry,” and with it, demand for pulpwood—the smaller-diameter wood and forest residuals that are most critical to remove for fire prevention. Sawmills are closing and biomass plants are shutting down. Every closure forces the remaining loggers to drive farther, spend more on diesel, and absorb losses that may eventually push them entirely out of the business.

Here’s the irony the “save a tree—go digital” crowd doesn’t see: the paper market is one of the primary economic engines that funds forest management. When consumers and companies buy paper, they’re supporting a supply chain that gives loggers a reason to bid on thinning contracts. When that demand disappears, so does the workforce and infrastructure that keeps forests healthy.

“It doesn’t matter what wood is available for sale if we don’t have a viable economic market,” Scott Dane, executive director of the American Loggers Council, told the Times. “Without markets, there is no forest management.”

While this isn’t an argument for cutting down old-growth forests or expanding logging into sensitive ecosystems, it is a call to recognize that managed forests need markets, and paper has long been one of the most important ones. Small trees, thinning, and residuals that reduce wildfire risk are among the materials pulp and paper mills use. Remove that demand, and you also remove the economic incentive to do the work.

The data on forest sustainability in North America remains strong. The United States grows nearly twice the volume of wood it harvests each year, and plants more than one billion trees annually. 

About 88 percent of the wood fiber used by the U.S. paper industry comes from privately owned, managed forests. The system works—but only when markets exist to sustain it.

For those of us who advocate for print and paper, this story reframes the conversation. The question isn’t whether paper harms forests. The question is what happens to forests when paper markets weaken. And the answer, playing out in real time across the American West, is: they are more susceptible to wildfire.

Choosing paper, whether it’s for books, packaging, direct mail, hygiene or magazines, isn’t a guilty pleasure—it’s an important product we use in our daily lives and participation in an economic cycle that funds the management our forests need. Every ream of paper, every printed book, every corrugated box represents demand for fiber that gives forest managers the resources to do their work.

Spread the love